What do the two moving quotes add up to?
Households enter the figures from their offers. The calculation separates handling time, the journey between homes and crew travel. All results are before taxes. The starting values demonstrate the tool and do not book a service.
An hourly figure and a fixed total answer different questions until the scope is clear. Households comparing Montreal moving costs can put the inventory, access and included work beside each offer before judging which arrangement fits their move.
Which moving quote is easier to budget for?
Start with the complete move
A fixed amount means little without the inventory, addresses, access and tasks it covers. Households ask both companies to price the same job before comparing totals.
Question the estimated hours
For an hourly quote, they ask what supports the estimate and recalculate with an extra hour. A small difference between two totals can disappear when the expected duration changes.
Check the exclusions
A flat rate that leaves out necessary bed assembly or an additional pickup needs those costs added. The useful figure is the comparable total for the service the household actually needs.
One company quotes $120 an hour. Another offers a $750 flat rate. The cheaper choice depends on the crew, truck, billable time and work included. Comparing the headline amounts alone leaves too much of the moving day unexplained.
This Montreal moving guide helps households compare flat-rate and hourly movers using a common inventory, itemized costs and realistic time assumptions. The scenarios below are illustrative calculations, not customer invoices or offers for a particular date.
Flat-rate and hourly moving: what changes?
With an hourly quote, the total follows the billable time and conditions agreed for the move. Households check the crew size, truck, minimum charge, travel charge and how the clock starts and stops. An estimate of five hours is different from a commitment to complete a defined job for a fixed amount.
A flat rate sets a price for a described service. The inventory, addresses, access, dates and inclusions matter just as much as the number on the quote. Adding a second pickup or asking the crew to pack a kitchen changes the requested job; households should have the revised scope and conditions confirmed in writing.
Neither pricing method describes service quality by itself. Two offers may both mention furniture protection while assigning different responsibilities for boxes, disassembly or putting furniture back together. Those details need a separate comparison.
Give both companies the same inventory
Apartment size provides context, but it does not count the load. Two 4½ apartments can contain very different quantities of furniture, books, appliances and cartons. Households list belongings room by room, including the storage locker, basement, balcony and anything waiting at a second address.
Useful photos show the furniture and the carrying route. The request should identify items needing disassembly and anything unusually heavy or awkward. An approximate box count and an honest description of what will be ready help the company estimate the work.
The same access information belongs in both requests: floors, stairs, elevator booking, truck parking and the distance from the vehicle to the entrance. The moving preparation guide helps organize those details before comparing offers.
Compare the inclusions line by line
| Item | Hourly offer | Flat-rate offer |
|---|---|---|
| Crew and truck | Confirm the rate for the whole crew and whether the truck is included. | Confirm the crew and vehicle covered by the amount. |
| Time | Check the estimate, minimum and billing increments. | Check any time or task limits and what happens if the agreed job takes longer. |
| Travel | Separate travel to and from the job from the journey between homes. Avoid counting either twice. | Have the covered route, return journey and extra stops specified. |
| Inventory | Ask which belongings support the time estimate. | Ask which belongings the fixed price covers and how additions are handled. |
| Packing | Identify labour and materials included or charged separately. | Identify the items and quantities included in the package. |
| Disassembly | List the furniture and whether reassembly is requested. | Confirm that those same tasks are included. |
| Elevator waiting | Confirm how waiting time is treated. | Clarify any condition or exclusion before accepting the offer. |
| Special items | Have the price and handling arrangements assessed for each declared item. | Have each piano, safe or other unusual item explicitly included. |
An unanswered line remains a question to resolve. “All included” becomes useful when the offer says exactly what the household and moving crew will each do.
Three worked examples: when does each offer cost less?
All amounts below are hypothetical and before taxes. The examples compare matching services; their durations are not forecasts for a particular apartment size. Travel is added only once.
Example A: a small, prepared load with straightforward access
Both offers cover two movers, a suitable truck and the same work. The hourly offer is $120/h, with a two-hour work minimum and one hour of crew travel. The flat rate is $480.
| Work duration | Hourly calculation | Hourly total | Flat rate |
|---|---|---|---|
| 2 hours | (2 + 1) × $120 | $360 | $480 |
| 3 hours | (3 + 1) × $120 | $480 | $480 |
| 4 hours | (4 + 1) × $120 | $600 | $480 |
The hourly offer is $120 lower in the first scenario. The totals match in the second. The flat rate is $120 lower in the third, provided it covers the complete agreed job. The deciding question is whether the time estimate reflects the actual inventory and access.
Example B: the flat rate excludes bed disassembly
An hourly quote estimates four hours of work, including disassembly, at $130/h plus one hour of travel. Its estimated total is $650. A flat-rate quote is $590, but excludes taking apart two beds. The written price for that additional work is $100.
The comparable flat-rate total is therefore $690, or $40 more than the hourly estimate. Comparing $590 against $650 would favour the incomplete offer. If the household takes the beds apart instead, it should also ask for the other company's time estimate to be reassessed.
The practical questions are who disassembles, who provides tools, who keeps the hardware and who reassembles. The answers need to match the service the household wants.
Example C: two movers or three?
For an inventory and access suitable for either proposal, two movers at $125/h with five estimated work hours and one travel hour total $750. Three movers at $175/h with three estimated work hours and one travel hour total $700.
The larger crew is $50 cheaper under those assumptions. If that crew takes four work hours, its total becomes $875. An additional mover does not guarantee a particular completion time. The company should explain the proposed crew and time estimate, and the crew must first be suitable for the handling involved.
Calculate the break-even point
When travel is charged in hours at the same rate and all other costs match, the comparison can use this formula:
Break-even work hours = (flat price ÷ hourly rate) − travel hours.
For $750 at a $120 hourly rate with one travel hour: 750 ÷ 120 − 1 = 5.25 work hours, or 5 hours 15 minutes.
If the hourly quote has an additional fixed charge absent from the flat rate, subtract that charge from the flat price before dividing. Minimum charges still apply. Where between-home driving is a separate input, subtract that time as well. This formula describes a financial threshold, not a prediction of moving time; billing increments can affect the precise billed total.
A lower hourly rate can still produce a higher minimum
A hypothetical $120/h offer with two minimum work hours and one travel hour starts at $360 before taxes. A $110/h offer with three minimum work hours and one travel hour starts at $440. The lower rate has the higher minimum in that comparison.
Households also check the journey between homes, how waiting is treated and any identified additional charges. The moving fees guide helps turn those questions into a complete offer comparison.
Prepare an offer around the actual move
Déménagement ALEX's French pricing page publishes low-season reference ranges of $115–135/h for two movers and a truck, and $160–185/h for three movers and a truck. Households should confirm the rate for their date, access and services. The English moving price guide provides the next planning steps.
A calculation already published by Déménagement ALEX
The example dated November 5, 2026 uses two movers and a truck at $115/h: three hours loading and unloading, fifteen minutes between the homes and one hour of crew travel.
(3 + 0.25 + 1) × $115 = $488.75 before taxes.
This is a published calculation example, not a documented customer invoice or an apartment-size package. The comparator starts with those values.
Local moves: separate the time components
Households distinguish handling time, the journey between addresses and crew travel. The cited pricing page describes a two-hour work minimum up to 30 km from Montreal, or three hours beyond 30 km and up to 80 km, based on the more distant address. The written offer must confirm the applicable conditions. The comparator accepts the minimum stated in the quote.
Long-distance moves: price the actual route
Beyond the local grid, the request should include postal codes, inventory, dates and receiving arrangements. A long-distance moving quote should specify its pricing method, covered services and exclusions. A flat rate needs written confirmation for that job; distance alone does not establish one.
Small loads and special items
A furniture delivery, piano and full apartment require different information. Dimensions, photos, floors, carrying routes and requested tasks help establish the work. Households can request a Déménagement ALEX quote with the same inventory used for their comparison.
Check access before relying on the estimate
Truck parking close to a ground-floor door creates a different job from a condo with a loading dock and a reserved elevator window. Households confirm the building rules and describe stairs, tight turns and long carrying distances at both addresses.
An assumed parking place is not a reserved space. An elevator booking should include the time window and relevant dimensions. If keys will not be available when the loaded truck arrives, the company needs to know before pricing the move. These details make the estimate more useful whichever pricing method is proposed.
What should be confirmed in writing?
- Crew size, truck and the complete inventory.
- Addresses, extra stops, floors and elevator arrangements.
- Hourly rate or flat amount, minimums and taxes.
- Crew travel, between-home driving and billing increments.
- Packing, materials, disassembly and reassembly.
- Identified extra charges and the handling of scope changes.
- Payment, cancellation and date-change conditions.
- Protection of belongings and the process for reporting a problem.
The Office de la protection du consommateur's moving guidance provides an independent reference for choosing a mover and requesting written information. Households retain the offer and exchanges that clarify the agreed job.
Get the actual move assessed
The date, addresses, inventory and access allow Déménagement ALEX to explain the proposed service and pricing.
Flat-rate versus hourly movers: common questions
Is flat-rate moving always cheaper?
No. In the illustrative $120/h comparison, four work hours plus one travel hour total $600, below a $750 flat rate. Six work hours plus one travel hour total $840, which makes that same flat rate $90 lower if it covers the identical job.
Does a five-hour estimate mean a five-hour flat rate?
No. A time estimate describes an expected duration. Households check whether the agreement bills actual time under stated conditions or fixes an amount for defined work. They also confirm minimums, travel and billing increments.
Can three movers cost less than two?
They can under a justified time estimate. Five work hours plus one travel hour at $125/h total $750. Three work hours plus one travel hour at $175/h total $700. The larger crew costs more if its actual billable time rises enough, and it must be appropriate for the handling.
What happens if furniture or another stop is added?
Households notify the company before moving day and ask whether the time estimate, vehicle, crew or flat price changes. They keep the updated scope and conditions in writing instead of assuming additions are automatically included.
Are the calculator results Déménagement ALEX quotes?
No. The tool compares the values entered under its displayed calculation convention. Its starting hourly example comes from a published ALEX calculation. A quote still requires the actual date, inventory, route, access and requested services.

